To me the first one doesn't look much like the original photo
Not at all unusual when buying from these Chinese websites!!
I almost never spend more than £2 or £3 on any item from there. That way, even if it turns out to be a total dud it is not the end of the world. It is often possible to get a refund as well. I can only think of one thing that was fairly awful but I have bought many things that have been absolute bargains. I have bought several craft dies for only a couple of pounds each instead of £10 or more on UK sites and a few kitchen bits and bobs too. It has enabled me to buy a lot more than I otherwise would and still be in pocket!! I'll take the odd dud!